Put-in-Bay Rentals - Company Logo

Vacation Rentals in Put-In-Bay →

House Rentals

House Rentals - The street front view of the All Star Ohio House.

The All Star Ohio House features the island’s best location, just steps from restaurants, nightlife, and Put-in-Bay Attractions!

House Rentals - Back view of The All-Star Ohio House on Put-in-Bay
House Rentals - A porch view of the All Star Ohio House.

The All Star Ohio House Is One Of Put-in-Bay’s Most Sought After House Rentals! Sleeps 22, 6 Bedrooms, 3 Bathrooms Right Downtown!

The All Star Ohio House Explore Put-in-Bay’s Top Rental Home!

Put-in-Bay’s Largest Modern Downtown Home Rental

When it comes to Put-in-Bay House Rentals, you can’t get any closer to the action than this! Just a one-minute walk from the main strip!

Great For Families & Large Groups!

Our newly renovated Six-Bedroom, Three-Bathroom home accommodates up to 22 guests comfortably and conveniently!

Photo Of Put-in-Bay Bars

Modern Well Equipped Kitchen with a BBQ Grill

Enjoy a cookout with family or friends and the game of the day on a 60″ TV with DirecTV & Wi-FI

Large Decks Front & Rear Perfect For Gathering!

Relax in comfort on our spacious front & back decks with Cornhole Games

Put-in-Bay - A vintage photo of the main strip showing bars, restaurants and shops.

About The All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Ohio

The All-Star Ohio House is Put-in-Bay’s premier rental house and one of the most sought-after home rentals at Put-in-Bay. Just steps from Delaware Avenue, the heart of the nightlife, and along DeRivera park and the downtown marina district, this modern home is like being at home!

Oftentimes referred to as the Buckeye House, this century-old residence was remodeled entirely & modernized to honor the Ohio State Buckeyes and additional notable Ohio Sports All-Stars!

Impeccably clean with modern attention to detail makes this Put-in-Bay Rental home the most desirable location for large parties, bachelor & bachelorette gatherings, family reunions, and other Put-in-Bay Events!!

House Rentals For 22 Guests- All-Star Ohio House- Put-in-Bays Modern Downtown Rental Home!

The contemporary All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Rental Home features six bedrooms and three bathrooms with a large living room & social area.
A modern, well-equipped kitchen allows guests to entertain and save money while cooking out on the large BBQ Grill, and TWO great private decks that are perfect for people-watching or enjoying the Put-in-Bay action!

The All Star Ohio House front deck looks out over Loraine Ave, one of the most active Put-in-Bay walking streets! Our rearward deck opens to a large secluded private patio with BBQ Grill, cornhole, and picnic tables. It’s decorated with Ohio Sports Memorabilia and mementos. Be sure to Contact Us with ANY questions you may have! You’ll also find many house rentals at Put-in-Bay require you to lug all your towels, linens & pillow along! Not here! You’re on vacation! Who wants to mess with that?

Put-in-Bay House Rentals – It’s All About Location!

Many House Rentals at Put-in-Bay are located in the center of the island, which is inconvenient, and are rustic homes. Our modern rental home eliminates the necessity for costly and time-consuming island transportation! The All-Star Ohio House has been named one of the best places to stay on Lake Erie!

Once you’ve settled in your Put-in-Bay Home Rental, you’re less than 300 feet from the island’s best restaurants, nightlife, shopping, and the Put-in-Bay Waterfront. You can walk less than two blocks and be at over 40 Put-in-Bay Restaurants or bars! Also close by is DeRivera park (great for kids), the Perry Peace Memorial, and the Put-in-Bay Ferry! 

The All-Star Ohio House allows you the convenience of being just a short walk from attractions, great shopping, historical sites and is less than one block from the famous Blue Marlin Pool Bar, the spot to be and be seen at Put-in-Bay! Be sure to Visit Our FAQ page! To discover Put-in-Bay, Click here!

Want To Learn About Everything Put-in-Bay?

Golf Cart Reservations

Click the link above to reserve your Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rental

Online Moped Reservations

Click the link to Reserve Your Moped Rentals In Advance!

Put-in-Bay Ohio Island Guide

Click the link above for the Put-in-Bay Ohio Iland Guide & explore South Bass Island

Put-in-Bay & The Best Hotels

Click the link above to learn about the three best hotels at Put-in-Bay!

Enter To Win A Free Weekend Stay!

Submit your entry to win one of 50 free weekend stays at Put-in-Bay awarded each season!

8 + 10 =